*except for Moneyball, which I saw in theaters when it came out.
Acting- Self explanatory. How good the acting is.
Production- All production aspects (special effects, music, etc.)
Script- How good the script is.
Oscarness- How well it fits into the type of movies the Oscars normally award.
Each will be graded out of 10. The 4 will be added up and have an overall score out of 40.
I'll make a new post after I've seen a couple more movies.